Posted by: sweeneyblog | July 27, 2013

From the Board Game Junkie: I Hate Monopoly

While I am a Political Junkie, I do actually have other interests outside of politics. Occasionally, I share my thoughts on subjects like Cynicism in Science Fiction, the marketing of John Carter or the viral nature of the Guy Fawkes mask. You can find all these articles under the heading “Time Wasters“. 

Monopoly is the quintessential board game. When people talk about friends or family gathering around a table and putting pieces on a board, they usually picture Monopoly. This bothers me immensely because Monopoly is a terrible game.

1935 Magazine Cover

History: Monopoly was originally conceived by Elizabeth Magie in 1903 as a way to demonstrate the evils of capitalism and the destructive ways that landowners can extort money from people. It was a mild success but it was not until 1935, when Parker Brothers bought out the patent and revamped the rules did it really take off.

With the Depression still dragging on, the game appealed because of the ability for average Americans to “own” such well-known landmarks as Marvin Gardens and Connecticut Avenue (spoiler: Connecticut Avenue is statistically the most profitable square on the board). So why is it so terrible?

It is poorly paced. Think about how it unfolds, four people sit down to play a game together. After an hour of playing, two players are knocked out of the game and the last two players are stuck for another three hours trying to bankrupt each other. It is frustrating for the people who have to sit out and it is aggravating for the two stuck in a final death spiral.

Compare it with another Parker Brother’s classic game: Life. When playing the game of Life, all the players finish the game roughly within fifteen minutes of each other. There are even squares on the board that allow slower players to take a second turn to “catch up.” That way everyone can conclude the game together and move on to the next activity as a group.

Risk: Great for tactics, lousy for geography

Risk: Great for tactics, lousy for geography

It is a zero sum game. For one person to gain money, they have to take it from another player. Sure there are a few  methods for obtaining money from the bank (“Collect $200 as you pass ‘go'”) but almost every action you can take is intended to extract money from other players, rather than build your own resources. This function is not bad, on its own. One of my all-time favorite games, Risk, is a zero-sum game (you only gain power by seizing countries from nearby players) however, combined with the poor pacing, this can make Monopoly deeply frustrating.

This is one of the reasons that cooperative games have become quite popular, where the players work together against the board game itself and they all either win or lose. Scotland Yard, where the players work together to locate a criminal hiding in the London Underground, is a classic example of a cooperative game.

Seattle-opoly

Finally, Monopoly is a sell-out. Now I’m no stranger to the corporate culture that has rapidly consumed the board game market, especially since Settlers of Catan brought adults back into the game buying world. Now the major board game companies pump out an expansion to popular games every year, however Monopoly has taken this one step further. They offer themed editions of games.

For example, you can purchase “Seattle-opoly,” except rather than showing popular well established local businesses, Monopoly auctions off squares on its own board to whichever local company is willing to pay a fee to appear on a square – making the board game more a function of buying power than actually reflecting the community it is supposedly featuring. This is in addition to the thousands of licensed other themes (Star Wars Monopoly, Pixar Monopoly, Pete Kremopoly, etc).

I guess there is a certain sort of dramatic irony in the fact that a game meant to illustrate the evils of capitalism has become the poster child for just that.

So next time you are considering a game to buy or play, consider one of these instead. It will save your game night from ending up just like these poor confused aliens:

Advertisements

Responses

  1. I’m a Dungeons and Dragons person. This page is fricking awesome…
    http://www.angelfire.com/games4/doctorwhoeyespy/free.html
    Nice!

  2. I am too lazy to photoshop a version of the “3 days without a workplace accident” tote board with “2 day since a mention of Pete Kremen on Riley’s blog” tote instead.

  3. Card Game: Set. With the various categories that can create a set. A card game where, once everyone understands it, kids can absolutely whup adults’ asses. This makes it really fun for everyone, and reminds us that adults are NOT smarter than kids. And they have an easier time thinking outside the box, having spent less time inside it.

    • My mother, and fellow Cribbage champion, had a theory that if you gave a game of set to a family with several children, there would always be one kid that would excel at it.

  4. I think that’s just what our mom said to make you and her feel better about your abysmal scores

    • Talk is cheap – pegging is what counts!

      • Pegging! Pegging! There is a short version of Monopoly and it does teach a bit of financial management to kids. Most of the older board games have value in that it means people have to sit and interact with each other. play by the rules and usually employ some creative thinking.

  5. I forgot to post about Atlantic City, the place the game is based on. Awkwardly and very tellingly, the cheapy properties such as Baltic and Mediterranian Avenues… have been razed, bulldozed, gentrified and turned into sterile parking lots. The former “low income residences” at those locations have been given the boot.

  6. Monopoly is the quintessential board game. When people talk about friends or family gathering around a table and putting pieces on a board, … gboardm.wordpress.com


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

%d bloggers like this: